Table of Contents
Errors in Nakahara's book
Geometry, Topology and Physics by Mikio Nakahara can be downloaded from the following online page.
(GradMikio Nakahara-Geometry, topology, and physics-Institute of Physics Publishing.pdf
http://staff.ustc.edu.cn/~hyx/0911/(GradMikio%20Nakahara-Geometry,%20topology,%20and%20physics-Institute%20of%20Physics%20Publishing.pdf
If you want to buy the published version, there is an Amazon page and you can get it anytime.
Amazon | Geometry, Topology and Physics, Second Edition (Graduate Student Series in Physics) | Nakahara, Mikio | Differential Geometry
https://www.amazon.co.jp/-/en/Mikio-Nakahara/dp/0750306068
1. Example 9.2.
Right after the equation (9.19), there is the following sentence:
This is wrong, although physicists and physics students don't care about such a thing.
Two vector fields and must be actually just vectors, that is,
and
.
Obviously, the author writes "a vector of " so is not a vector field. Similarly, is a vector.
2. Section 9.2
Just below the equation (9.10), the author writes the definition of a section.
He writes the set of sections of a fiber bundle as ,
which is incorrect. A section maps a point on the base space to an element of the total space.
In fact, the following example is the sections on , , where the tangent bundle is not a fiber but the total space.
Correctly, the formula is
.
cf. Section (fiber bundle) - Wikipedia
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_(fiber_bundle)
3. Section 10.1.3
Below Figure 10.2 in section 10.1.3, he writes
where we have noted that
but this is wrong. That's because is not a point on .
In this section, is a principal bundle. In other words, given a fiber bundle , the total space is and being a principal bundle gives by definition.
Projection
In section 9.2.1, a differentiable fiber bundle is defined and the projection is important in this case:
(iv) A surjection called the projection. The inverse image is called the fiber at .
A fiber at is a subset of and just needed to be diffeomorphic to the typical fiber . If we rewrite it into a mathematical formula,
.
Section
Def.
Let be a fiber bundle. A section (or a cross section) is defined as
- smooth (differentiable fiber bundle) or homeomorphic (topological fiber bundle).
By definition, the value of a section at , , is an element of a fiber over , , i.e.
and .
The set of (global) sections on is denoted by (not ).
Here, a local section is an element of , where is an open set of the base space .
Let be a point on , then . Therefore, the correct sentence is
.
Summary
I found three errors in the contents of Nakahara's book.
- Not vector fields, but vectors.
- Sections are the total space -valued functions.
- Misprint about a tangent space.